Posts Categorized: Retiree Benefits

Supreme Court Upholds Contract Law for ERISA Plans

in Court Cases, Retiree Benefits

Today the Supreme Court upheld ordinary notions of contract law in interpreting ERISA plans, thereby apparently defeating the so-called “Yard-Man Inference.” In Yard-Man, the Sixth Circuit found a provision governing retiree insurance benefits ambiguous as to the duration of those benefits using two major theories.  First, the court inferred an intent to vest those benefits for life, under an illusory promise theory.  Second, the court relied on the context of labor negotiations to resolve ambiguities about vesting the benefits for life. The Supreme Court stated that the inferences applied in Yard-Man and its progeny do not represent ordinary principles of… Continue Reading